Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Analyzing indicators of two countries seriously tackling the ICT market: Kenya and Rwanda

For the last ten years, African leaders made many declarations about the importance of ICT for their development without much result so far.  Here is a non-exhaustive list of some of those declarations:

Blantyre, Malawi – 2001
Southern African Development Community needs a coherent regional policy and strategy on Information and Communications Technology, signed by 13 heads of governments
Geneva, 12 December 2003
The World Summit on the Information Society: 44 Heads of State, Prime Ministers, Presidents, Vice-Presidents approve plan of Action which sets forth a road map to build on that vision and to bring the benefits of ICT to underserved economies.
Khartoum,  Sudan - 2006
African Regional Action Plan on the Knowledge Economy (ARAPKE) adopted by the Executive Council of the African Union
Sharm El-Sheikh, Egypt  - 2008
13th Ordinary Session of the Executive Council in calling on the AU Commission to take the necessary measures to speed up the implementation of the Reference Framework for Harmonization for Telecommunication ICT Policy and Regulation
Addis Ababa, Ethiopia - in 2009
African Heads of State and Government Declaration on supporting the Program for Infrastructure Development in Africa (PIDA)
Johannesburg - November 2009
Oliver Tambo Declaration adopted by the African Union Ministers in charge of Communication and Information Technologies
Addis Ababa, Ethiopia  - 2 February 2010
14th Assembly of Heads of State and Government Declaration on Information and Communication Technologies in Africa
Abuja, Nigeria - 7 August 2010
Africa’s Information Communications Ministers Resolve to Push ICT Sector at Continental Level
Brazzaville, Congo - 3 May 2011
African health ministers have called for the use of information and communication technologies 
Cape Town, South Africa - 4 June 2012
The Ministers responsible for Information Communication Technologies (ICTs) declare common desire and commitment to eradicate the barriers of poverty through the promotion and use of enabling ICTs

In this posting we analyze two countries that have "walked the talk" and started implementing real ICT strategies: Kenya and Rwanda.

The following comparative analysis begins by applying political, social, economic and technical metrics to both countries. Then we will compare global competitiveness and networked readiness indices of both countries.

This analysis utilizes publicly available data from recognized world organization and that is no older than two years (see links to data sources in Appendix).

Here are the metrics and indicators I selected:

1) Education

- Literacy rate:  % of people aged 15 and above who can, with understanding, read and write a short, simple statement on their everyday life.
- Quality of higher education (HE)
While one can find many publications about methods of evaluation of higher education quality, there are very few rankings of HE quality by country, and when they exist they don't cover Africa. Therefore I used the world ranking of the best university in the country (www.webometrics.info) as an estimate for the quality of tertiary education in that country. 

2) Business environment

- Ease of doing business: starting a business, dealing with construction permit, getting electricity, registering property, getting credit, protecting investors, paying taxes, trading across borders, enforcing contract, and resolving insolvency.
- Corruption perception index: capturing perceptions of the extent of corruption in the public sector, from the perspective of business people and country experts.
- Total tax rate: sum of profit tax, labor tax and social contributions, property taxes, turnover taxes, and other taxes, as a share (%) of commercial profits.
- Quality of infrastructure: transport, telephony and energy.

3) Political, economic and social environment

- Democracy: electoral process and pluralism; functioning of government; political participation; political culture; civil liberties.
- Good governance: voice and accountability; political stability and absence of violence; government effectiveness; regulatory quality; rule of law; control of corruption.
- GDP/Capita: gross domestic product divided by midyear population.
- GDP growth rate: annual percentage growth rate of GDP at market prices based on constant local currency.
- Quality of life: based on economy, environment, freedom, health infrastructure, risk & safety, and climate.

In Africa the relationship between  economic development and democracy is less clear than between economic development and good governance as explained in an article recently published in African Business (French edition), Dec 2012-Jan 2013 by Ch. d'Alayer.
The measurement of good governance is controversial and difficult, as explained in a report by Marie Besancon from the World Peace Foundation at Harvard University. In her report she mentions that "the most comprehensive set of global governance indicators has been compiled by the World Bank and combines subjective and objective attributes" which I'm using here. I have extracted the following graphics from that World Bank report. I calculated the average of the 6 indicators' percentile for each country as a total estimate for good governance.
Graphic color coding:

 





 4) Government ICT Drive

As discussed earlier, governments need to play a key role in establishing a favorable environment for the development of an ICT industry. I have selected two indicators about the government ICT drive:
- Government prioritization of ICT: How much priority does the government places on information and communication technologies?
- Importance of ICT to government vision of the future: To what extent does the government have a clear implementation plan for utilizing information and communication technologies to improve the country’s overall competitiveness?

Comparing Kenya’s and Rwanda’s rankings

Below is a table comparing Kenya and Rwanda’s rankings in each metric outlined above. Green indicates the country with the advantage (WR = World Ranking)

Kenya is leading in:
- Education: Kenya has a better literacy rate and their top university is ranked significantly higher. Kenya's best university is the University of Nairobi ranked 1435th in the world, Rwanda's best university is the National University of Rwanda ranked 4157th. This better quality of tertiary education is informally confirmed by feedback I receive from business people hiring in both countries. While Kenya has a clear advantage, it is only relative. Indeed, when looking at successful "Silicon Valley" types of development, they have been driven by world-class universities ranked in the top 100, like Stanford University in the Bay area, MIT in the Boston area, the National University of Singapore in Singapore, or the Technion-Israel Institute of Technology in Haifa. Clearly one of the major challenges for the development of a Silicon Valley in Africa will be the quality of higher education to deliver the talent to work on the development of high-tech ICT innovation.  The hope for Rwanda is that the recent opening of a Carnegie Mellon University (CMU) branch in Kigali will impact the quality of higher education in the country.
- Democracy: Kenya's advantage is mainly based on the electoral process, pluralism and the political participation.
- GDP/capita: Kenya is the region's leading economy
- Quality of life: Kenya's advantage is built on leisure and culture, freedom and climate.

Rwanda is leading in all other indicators.
- Ease of doing business: Rwanda’s advantages are particularly in starting a business, getting electricity and registering property, protecting investors, paying taxes, and enforcing contracts. It is still lagging in construction permit, getting credit and resolving insolvency.
- Corruption perception index: Rwanda has a significant advantage here, being ranked 4th in Africa after Botswana, Cape Verde and Mauritius. Compared to Kenya, its advantage is based on performance and institutional assessment, executive opinion survey, and bank governance rating.
- Total tax rate: This criterion is more difficult to assess as there is often a difference between official tax rates and actual tax rates due to different loopholes in tax legislation. In particular for IT, one can expect governments to offer tax free zones for the development of IT businesses. For instance in Rwanda, all IT equipment can be imported tax free.
- Quality of infrastructure: Available data does not provide detail about the countries' scores for the indicators used (transport, telephony and energy). Based on my personal experience, traffic jams in Nairobi represent a very serious problem when it comes to move from one location to another; it can easily take hours to cover only a few miles. This can have a significant impact on the dynamic of the development of an ICT ecosystem as discussed later in this posting.
- Good governance: Here again Rwanda' score is significantly better mainly due to political stability/absence of violence, rule of law and control of corruption (see graphics above).
- GDP growth rate: Rwanda’s economy has enjoyed high growth rates (6-8%) for the last decade. Last year its GDP growth rate was the 14th in the world. As a result Rwanda has lifted more than one million people out of poverty.
- Priority of ICT and importance of ICT for the government: Rwanda is ranked significantly higher than Kenya, being ranked third in the world for those criteria behind Singapore and Sweden. But is the drive of the government of Rwanda (GoR) enough? We will discuss it in the second part of the analysis.


Global Competitiveness

Based on the World Economic Forum’s Global Competitiveness Report 2012-2013, the following table compares the Global Competitiveness Index (CGI) of Kenya and Rwanda for the last three years.



Global competitiveness is based on indicators grouped in three categories with different weights:
1) Basic requirements (60%): institutions, infrastructure, macroeconomic environment, health and primary education
2) Efficiency enhancers (35%): higher education and training, goods market efficiency, labor market efficiency, financial market development, technological readiness, market size
3) Innovation and sophistication factors (5%): business sophistication, innovation

It is interesting to observe how Rwanda's global competitiveness as measured by the GCI is better than Kenya's. In fact, Rwanda’s GCI is improving as Kenya's GCI is stagnating over the last three years. Let’s look at the details.
The following graphic provides the details of the indicators entering the composition of the CGI. Indicators derived from the survey are expressed as scores on a 1-7 scale, with 7 being the most desirable outcome. I integrated the scores for both Rwanda and Kenya in the same graphic for easier comparison.




Rwanda and Kenya score 5 and 4, respectively, tying for three indicators. Kenya has the advantage for the following indicators: higher education, confirming previous data; financial market development, pushed by the presence of multinational corporations; technological readiness; and market size, mainly due to the size of its economy as Kenya's GDP is more than five times the size of Rwanda's GDP. Rwanda leads in institutions, macroeconomic environment, health & primary education, good market efficiency, and labor efficiency, confirming its advantage in ease of doing business and good governance from previous data.

Networked Readiness Index 

 

One of the most authoritative exercises to measure and benchmark ICT developments is the Networked Readiness Index (NRI) available in the World Bank and INSEAD’s Global Information Technology Report 2012, which has been adopted by several governments as a valuable tool for assessing and leveraging technology for competitiveness and development.
The NRI comprises four sub-indices that measure the environment for ICT; the readiness of a society to use ICT; the actual usage of all main stakeholders; and, finally, the impacts that ICT generates in the economy and society. These four sub-indexes are divided into 10 pillars: 1. Political and regulatory environment; 2. Business and innovation environment; 3. Infrastructure and digital content; 4. Affordability; 5. Skills; 6. Individual usage; 7. Business usage; 8. Government usage; 9. Economic impacts; 10. Social impacts.



The following graphic provides the details of the NRI indicators for both countries integrated in the same graphic.

In contrast to the GCI, both countries score 3 each while they tie in three criteria. Kenya's advantages are in affordability; skills, confirming again the better quality of its education; and individual usage, due probably to higher penetration of technology in the country. Mobile phone penetration is 65% in Kenya versus 41% in Rwanda (it is projected to increase to 60% this year after the arrival of Airtel in Rwanda) and Kenya’s internet penetration rate is quadruple that of Rwanda at 28% versus 7%, respectively. It should come as no surprise that Rwanda is leading or equal in all other indicators- mostly relating to public sector interventions- including in political & regulatory environment, business and innovation environment, and government usage.

You will fnd a more detailed analysis and comparison in my next posting.

Seeya later alligator...


APPENDIX

The following links have been used to collect the data used in this posting:
- Literacy rate (2010): World Bank Literacy rate (% of people ages 15 and above)
- World ranking of best university (2012): Webometrics
- Ease of doing business (2012): Doing Business.org/World Bank
- Corruption perception index (2012): Transparency International 
- Inflation rate (2012): SID: The State of East Africa 2012 page 65
- Total tax rate (2012): The World Economic forum: The Global IT Report 2012 page 336
- Quality of overall infrastructure (2012): INSEAD/The World Economic Forum: The Global Competitiveness Report 2012 page 412
- Democracy (2011): Economist Intelligence Unit: Democracy Index 2011 (requires free registration for access)  
- Good Governance (2011): World Bank: Worldwide Governance Indicators
- GDP per Capita (2011): The World Bank
- GDP growth rate (2011): The World Bank
- Quality of life (2010): International Living
- Government prioritization of ICT (2012): The World Economic forum: The Global IT Report 2012 page 374
- Importance of ICT to government vision of the future (2012): The World Economic forum: The Global IT Report 2012 page 375

Saturday, February 23, 2013

OLPC: from MIT lab to the reality on the ground

The One Laptop Per Child (OLPC) organization was founded by Nicholas Negroponte with the mission to empower the world's poorest children through education. OLPC is a Delaware-based, non-profit organization created by faculty members from the MIT Media Lab to design, manufacture, and distribute laptops that are sufficiently inexpensive to provide every child in the world access to knowledge and modern forms of education.

Their flagship product is the XO computer.
Source: engadget.com

Initially known as the $100 Laptop, the XO was designed in the early 2000s to cost less than $100 but ended up costing $200 which was still an incredible technical achievement at that time when laptop computers’ cost was exceeding $1,000.

The OLPC program is a great concept and many countries have invested in acquiring OLPC XO  computers for their schools: Argentina, Brazil, Libya, Nigeria, Rwanda, Thailand, and Uruguay. Negroponte told TIME in an e-mail interview: "We want Rwanda to be a showcase." But was it a good choice for Rwanda?

Last summer, four students from Carnegie Mellon University came to Rwanda to help a local school deploy OLPC XO computers to 300 fifth grade kids. Here is an excerpt of the CMU students’ report:
“Project Rwanda 2012 is a Carnegie Mellon University student-run program dedicated to empowering Rwandan youths through technology and arts education. From August 16th-24th 2012, four students from Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh taught interactive lessons to 300 students at the St. Vincent Pallotti School in the Gikondo district of Kigali. 
5th grade kids at St Vincent Pallotti School in Kigali

Utilizing XO laptops provided by One Laptop Per Child (OLPC) and their own creative imaginations, the students explored a number of ways that they could cultivate their unique talents.  The core subjects covered in these lessons included computer programming, keyboarding, and fine arts.   From animated game development using the Scratch software to performative reenactments of their favorite pastimes, the students had the opportunity to engage themselves in a wide variety of fun learning activities.  Not only did the students enjoy themselves while actively participating in these educational exercises, but they also taught their teachers a wealth of information about their fascinating culture.  We are incredibly excited to share these inspiring personal stories with the Carnegie Mellon University community in Pittsburgh, and we cannot wait to see how the students continue to further their interests in technology and the arts!” – report written by Sara Faradji, CMU student leading the project.

While the project was a success, I want to share some reality faced on the ground by the CMU students when using the OLPC XO computers. Between a product conceived by smart people in developed countries and the reality on the ground in Africa there is often a gap. The major problem encountered was the computers’ battery lifetime. The average battery lifetime was 2.5-3 hours maximum (these were brand new computers) which corresponds to the average battery life of 3 hrs announced by OLPC. It seems that the computers were equipped with low quality batteries to keep the cost low (below $200).
What is the impact of that battery life limitation for the school in Rwanda? The school has received more than 900 XO computers and there are only two power plugs for all the classrooms in the school. Considering that it takes three hours for a full recharge of the battery, you can imagine the nightmare for recharging 900+ computers every day. The CMU students had to take a maximum of batteries back to their hotel every night for recharging them. When talking with the local OLPC representative about this problem, he told me that they were going to help the school installing more power plugs. But that is not the solution. The reason why there are only two power plugs in the school is that they want to limit usage of electricity as it is very expensive. The cost of electricity in Rwanda is twice the cost of neighboring countries. A quick calculation showed that the cost of recharging the 900 computers every day for one month would be equivalent to the salary of one teacher. The best solution seems to be for the students to take their computer with them back home and charging it at home over night. That is if they have electricity at home which is mostly the case in Kigali, but not in rural areas. Electricity penetration in Rwanda is only 16 %.

Another problem encountered was keys and buttons breaking after less than two weeks usage. It was not clear how those could be repaired even if OLPC claims that XO computers are designed to be repaired quickly in the field by users with a minimum of training.

So it seems to me that the XO computer is not appropriate for Rwanda from a technical point of view. Even more so that today, 8 years after its design, you can buy a Netbook in Africa for less than $200, i.e. cheaper than the XO. It is true that XO is loaded with special education software that was specially designed for it. The cost of installing this software should be added to the cost of the Notebook for a fair comparison.

In another posting published in 2010, I explained that a better solution could be tablets or iPods. They offer the advantage to have longer battery life but also they don’t have keyboards and buttons that can easily break. Keyboards and buttons are virtually represented on the screen. But more importantly they are examples of real mobile internet devices that will be used in Africa in the coming years. In addition, solar panels on the back of these devices could help with recharging the battery at no cost. A couple of years ago, OLPC claimed to be working on such a solution showed in my 2010 blog posting, but no news since then. Instead they seem to try to sell their inappropriate XOs which they build by the millions to get their money back ... at the cost of poor Rwanda!

Seeya later alligator...

Wednesday, February 20, 2013

Rwanda's Historic Health Recovery: What the U.S. Might Learn

Dear readers,

I  just want to share a very interesting article published today in The Atlantic by Neal Emery is a Chicago-based writer who focuses on public health.

Enjoy the reading.

Friday, January 25, 2013

A nice report from Lee Razo about his visit to Carnegie Mellon University in Rwanda

Last year I received the visit of Lee Razo, founder of Datasphere Systems from Amsterdam, Netherlands.


Lee is an IT professional with about 20 years in the industry in both the Silicon Valley and in Europe. With a business partner, he was looking into the possibility of doing business in East Africa. We met in my office and I recall a very interesting conversation. He published a nice report about that visit in his blog "Exploring Business in Africa" and I want to share that report with my blog readers here.
Here is the link to it. Enjoy the reading and thank you Lee for the report.

Seeya later alligator...

Sunday, December 16, 2012

Africa must take IP protection seriously for its entrepreneurs to succeed

Last September I attended the Startup World event in Kigali Rwanda. Startup World is a global competition for startups based on a concept similar to American Idol to find the next startup idol. The difference is that instead of having all the startups coming to one location to compete, the Startup World team is organizing events in 37 cities worldwide on all continents recognizing the fact that Silicon Valley is not an exclusive source of innovation.

This is a great idea and the dynamic Startup World team is doing miracles to make this a success. We were lucky here in Kigali to host one event and it generated a lot of interest in the community. As one of the founding members of kLab, the new innovation center in Kigali, I helped some of our members applying and preparing for that competition. It is actually one of them who won the contest.

The winner will ge invited to travel to Silicon Valley to pitch before venture capitalists. And this is where I start to get concerned. When talking with the Startup World organizers, I asked them if they provided any protection for the Intellectual Property (IP) of the participants? They did not and said that it should be the responsibility of each participant. The reality is that generally these young African entrepreneurs have very little understanding about IP protection. How many times did I meet these young entrepreneurs and they would share with me their idea or projects without any protection. I know some who did share their good project with local telecoms. They asked for a meeting and naively shared their project with the telco representatives without any non-disclosure agreement (NDA) being signed or without any recording that such a meeting even took place!

There seems to be more and more of these competitions for innovators in Africa and so far I have not seen any of them explicitly addressing the IP protection problem. Then they send the winners in front of VCs in California!?!? Guess what will happen...

But the ones to blame are not these competition organizers, neither the VCs that will benefit from their efforts. What is needed here is for Africa to start seriously addressing the IP problem at the continent level. If Africa wants its innovators to succeed, it needs to provide them with the adequate protection for their inventions. Without that IP protection Africa may see one more time its resources, in this case its intellectual resources, exploited by foreign organizations. 

This is probably what happened with M-Pesa. Safaricom is being sued by the creator of M-Pesa for theft of his idea/invention. No patent was ever filed in Kenya, and none would have been issued because Kenya does not allow business method patents or software patents. Actually  it is Vodafone Group Services Limited incorporated in England that owns M-Pesa and not Safaricom as is the popular belief in Kenya. Strangely there is very little credible information about that case on the Web.

At the minimum, my recommendation for young entrepreneurs sharing their innovation with third parties, is to get them to sign a Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) sometimes also called a Confidentiality Agreement. These can be found on Internet, here is an example. At the minimum, the agreement should include the definition of what information is shared, the explanation of the purpose of the disclosure and the identification of the people and company to which is it disclosed with time, date and location. This will at least send a clear signal to the third party that you are taking the protection of your IP seriously. If the third party refuses to sign such an agreement, it will also clearly indicate that they may not be seriously considering a partnership with you, in which case you should run away.

IP protection laws have been the foundation for the development of successful innovative corporations like Apple, IBM, etc. (see the recent Apple-Samsung patent dispute). 
The US has its own Patent Office, so does Europe and many countries in all continents...except for Africa. I could not find a patent office from any African country in this list of patent offices in the world, while I know there are some, at least here in Rwanda.

What is needed is to deploy one Patent Office for all of Africa. Patent Offices are expansive and most individual country in Africa cannot afford it. By coordinating efforts at the continent level Africa can reduce the cost and at the same time provide protection in all the countries in Africa at once.

Such a  Pan-African IP Organization has been in the works at the African Union but the project is already under criticism by experts and it may take long before it becomes operational. We need to find interim solutions. The World IP Organization (WIPO) has issued an interesting document about "Guidelines on Developing Intellectual Property Policy For Universities and R&D Institutions in African Countries". Next is the need for educating entrepreneurs about IP protection and providing them with the means of using it. Applying for a patent is a complex process. We at CMU-Rwanda are planning to have IP protection eduction for our graduate students with the help of WIPO.

Let's make sure that the next African innovation benefits its inventors and Africa.

Seeya later alligator... 

Sunday, November 25, 2012

Kigali the cleanest, safest, fastest and most liveable city in Africa

In the last couple of weeks, several reports came out ranking Kigali and Rwanda on top that I would like to share with you, particularly for those of you for whom Rwanda is still associated with the genocide memory.

1) Rwanda the safest place in Africa.

The Gallup’s World Poll — the only global study of its kind — spans more than 150 countries. Gallup typically surveys 1,000 adults in each country at least once a year, using a standard set of core questions that Gallup translates into the major languages of the respective country. In their last report "Global States of Mind: New Metrics for world leaders" published in October 2012, Rwanda tops the ranking of countries where people feel safe in front of Georgia, Qatar and Singapore. This is based on people's sense of personal security in their neighborhoods and their personal experiences with crime and law enforcement. One of our Chinese students who recently spent 10 weeks in Kigali said "I often worked in CMU Rwanda campus till about 1 AM and went back to my hotel. I felt it very very safe. I was no longer worried about security issue like in the US."

2) Kigali cleanest city in Africa

A recent report by CNN: "Kigali's clean vision for the future" is explaining why dirtiness does not need to be necessarily associated with poverty. It is a question of culture and sensitizing the population to it. It is also about country leaders and authority participating in the process. Here is another report from the Chinese CCTV about Kigali being the cleanest and safest city in Africa.

3) Rwanda tops Africa in broadband speed

Rwanda has the fastest broadband Internet in Africa, according to latest statistics from Ookla’s NetIndex, overtaking Ghana. Based on millions of recent test results from Speedtest.net, this index compares and ranks consumer download speeds around the globe. The value is the rolling mean throughput in Mbps over the past 30 days where the mean distance between the client and the server is less than 300 miles. The average download speed in Rwanda is 6.29 Mbps, the fastest in Africa. This does not describe the global download speed, but only the local speed (within 300 km). This is probably due to the fact that Rwanda has one of the densest optical networks in Africa, over 3,000 km of optical fiber in a country not larger than 300 km.

4) Kigali in the top 10 most liveable cities in Africa

In an Africa.com blog posting, Kigali is ranked tenth most liveable city in Africa in a ranking headed as expected by Cape Town. A good city development master plan and road constructions have made Kigali a well organized city with very little traffic congestion, especially compared to its neighboring capitals like Nairobi, Kampala or Dar es Salaam where I spent hours in traffic jams with the taxi sometimes barely moving more than 1 km in one hour. In addition to 4-5 stars hotel like the Serena Hotel or the upcoming new Marriott hotel, Kigali also offers nice boutique hotels like the Inside Africa ranked in the best boutique hotels in Africa.

I hope you enjoy this posting and that someday I'll meet you in Kigali the safest, cleanest, fastest and more liveable city in Africa.

Seeya later alligator....